Ratings

ProPain · 25-03-2005, 10:10

Untill now the proposed line-ups in Hattrick Ratings and Hattrick Org. were always very similar for my team.

Today I saw some shifts in player form which resulted in HR and HO giving quite different results in player rating and hence line up.

What do you guys reckon is the most accurate tool HO or HR? Or do you maybe use another tool that you consider superior to both HR and HO?

Kingreno · 25-03-2005, 10:27

I use only HO, but last months the ratings it gives are way off the ratings I get after the matches. Also, the training tool in the new version of HO is malfunctioning completely.

ProPain · 25-03-2005, 10:51

Don't get me started on the new training tool of HO. I even kept an old 1.23 version just for the old training tool.

Kemal · 25-03-2005, 10:58

Since I can't get HR to work on my system for whatever reasons, I can only comment on HO and so far that has been all I've needed really.

Ratings have always been very close to the actual match ratings for me (maybe it starts to malfunction at higher level players?), though its prediction of stars per player is way, way off (doesn't bother me much though). The training tool seems to work fine for keepers, but I guess that's not a surprise with the keeper's level calculations being so easy to make.

Kingreno · 25-03-2005, 11:07

Training for Defenders is impossible to predict with HO's help. One went from Formidable to Outstanding this morning, yet after downloading the HRF, the training assistant told me he was at 9.5/10 weeks. There also players at 13/11 that have not popped! HO is clueless whether I played them as inner mids (no training) or Defenders (full training).
IMHO once a player has "popped", knowing the intensiity and coach skill, it can't be taht hard to make very accurate predictions when the next pop will be...HO however seems to be unable to do this!

Dell19 · 25-03-2005, 12:00

Actually there is meant to be some variation as someone may have only just have popped to the previous level and then take an extra week to pop, or may be the opposite case and end up popping a week earlier. HT Ratings seems pretty accurate and tends to get stars right. It does have difficulty predicting my attack ratings though.

yndy · 27-03-2005, 08:01

I'm not using any predictor as I can generally tell by looking at my previous matches and updating for form, training abd positionig of players. I started twice to build my own predictor but gave up.

25-03-2005, 10:10	#1
ProPain Customized Admin :) Join Date: Mar 2003 Location: sailing the seas of cheese. Posts: 5,852	Ratings Untill now the proposed line-ups in Hattrick Ratings and Hattrick Org. were always very similar for my team. Today I saw some shifts in player form which resulted in HR and HO giving quite different results in player rating and hence line up. What do you guys reckon is the most accurate tool HO or HR? Or do you maybe use another tool that you consider superior to both HR and HO? __________________ I fed my Dog the American Dream Well, he rolled over and he started to scream He said, I dig the taste of salt but it don't keep me alive yeah, yeah

25-03-2005, 10:27	#2
Kingreno Moderator Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Netherlands. Posts: 3,270	I use only HO, but last months the ratings it gives are way off the ratings I get after the matches. Also, the training tool in the new version of HO is malfunctioning completely. __________________ Go ahead punk. Make my day.

25-03-2005, 10:51	#3
ProPain Customized Admin :) Join Date: Mar 2003 Location: sailing the seas of cheese. Posts: 5,852	Don't get me started on the new training tool of HO. I even kept an old 1.23 version just for the old training tool. __________________ I fed my Dog the American Dream Well, he rolled over and he started to scream He said, I dig the taste of salt but it don't keep me alive yeah, yeah

25-03-2005, 10:58	#4
Kemal Join Date: Mar 2003 Location: Netherlands. Posts: 3,108	Since I can't get HR to work on my system for whatever reasons, I can only comment on HO and so far that has been all I've needed really. Ratings have always been very close to the actual match ratings for me (maybe it starts to malfunction at higher level players?), though its prediction of stars per player is way, way off (doesn't bother me much though). The training tool seems to work fine for keepers, but I guess that's not a surprise with the keeper's level calculations being so easy to make. __________________ <b>\"In the Game of Thrones, you win or you die\" </b>

25-03-2005, 11:07	#5
Kingreno Moderator Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Netherlands. Posts: 3,270	Training for Defenders is impossible to predict with HO's help. One went from Formidable to Outstanding this morning, yet after downloading the HRF, the training assistant told me he was at 9.5/10 weeks. There also players at 13/11 that have not popped! HO is clueless whether I played them as inner mids (no training) or Defenders (full training). IMHO once a player has "popped", knowing the intensiity and coach skill, it can't be taht hard to make very accurate predictions when the next pop will be...HO however seems to be unable to do this! __________________ Go ahead punk. Make my day.

25-03-2005, 12:00	#6
Dell19 King Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Grantham. Posts: 1,359	Actually there is meant to be some variation as someone may have only just have popped to the previous level and then take an extra week to pop, or may be the opposite case and end up popping a week earlier. HT Ratings seems pretty accurate and tends to get stars right. It does have difficulty predicting my attack ratings though.

27-03-2005, 08:01	#7
yndy Prince Join Date: May 2003 Location: Romania. Posts: 895	I'm not using any predictor as I can generally tell by looking at my previous matches and updating for form, training abd positionig of players. I started twice to build my own predictor but gave up. __________________ The one and only